🎉 Up to 70% Off Selected ItemsShop Sale

Home Shop Cart Account

Vibrators
Dildos
Men's Toys
Anal Toys
Couples and BDSM
Lingerie
Lubes and Essentials
Shop by Experience

All Butt Plugs

All Butt Plugs

Price

Min

-

Max

Collections

All Products For ReviewBest Pleasure Products For Men Under $501.26 - 1.75 Inch Thick7 Inch DildosAlivia's Top Vday PicksAll LubesAll Anal ToysAdult Novelties9 Inch Plus Dildos2 Inch Plus Thick DildosBest Deals Under $10Alivia's Top PicksA-Spot StimulationAir Sex ToysAlivia's Most Recommended GiftsBeginner VibratorsBest Male ToysAll Suction ToysAdult Games1.76 - 1.99 Inch Thick

Subscribe to our newsletter for exclusive offers, new arrivals, and style inspiration.

Shop

All Products
New Arrivals
Sale

Company

Shipping Info
FAQ
Contact Us

About

About Us
Returns
Privacy

© 2026 TooTimid.com. All rights reserved.

Colt Expandable Butt Plug

$59.95

0% OFF

-65%

High Intensity Vibro Tease Plug

$41.95

$14.68

65% OFF

-65%

Naughty Candy Heart Anal Plug

$29.95

$10.48

65% OFF

-65%

Crystal Jellies Anal Starter Kit

$52.95

$18.53

65% OFF

-65%

Dare 10-Function Silicone Anal Toy

$59.95

$20.98

65% OFF

-65%

Flexi Plug Anal Toy

$19.95

$6.98

65% OFF

-65%

Rump Rockers 3pc Silicone Anal Training Set

$40.95

$14.33

65% OFF

-65%

Pretty Jewel Butt Plug

$14.95

$5.23

65% OFF

-65%

Silicone Anal Plug Kit

$69.95

$24.48

65% OFF

-65%

#1 Anal Silicone Anal Training Kit For Beginners

$49.95

$17.48

65% OFF

-65%

Silicone Anal Plug With Flared Base

$19.95

$6.98

65% OFF

-65%

Rippled Silicone Anal Plug With Flat Suction Base

$34.95

$12.23

65% OFF